# Value Trap Test for Cheap Stocks A stock can be cheap and stay cheap. The test asks three questions and multiplies the answers. $ \text{Conviction} = P(\text{fair price is right}) \times P(\text{market corrects}) \times P(\text{inside my horizon}) $ ## The rule - If the "market corrects" leg is below 0.5, the app flags a value trap. - A cheap price is not enough. A catalyst must make the market change its view. ## Silicon2 example (13 Nov 2026) | Leg | Value | Why | |---|---|---| | Fair price is right | 0.70 | Even the bear case is above the price. | | Market corrects | 0.44 | The catalyst is not sure. | | Inside my horizon | 1.00 | The Q4 report comes in about Feb 2027. | | **Conviction** | **0.31** | moderate | - My catalyst: "the Q4 report shows inventory continues to fall and the margin is above 18%." Certainty: 0.4. - A certainty of 0.46 or more on the catalyst clears the flag. - Q3 made me more sure on inventory and less sure on margins. Thus I kept 0.4. ## How to use it 1. Write the catalyst as a test that a report can pass or fail. 2. Give the catalyst a certainty before the report comes. 3. Make the position size match the conviction, not the upside. ---- tags: #boat #investing #concept links: [[Silicon2 MOC]] [[Investing Principles]] [[Silicon2 Valuation]]